Easy Skittles Cookies

By Danielle Nieman

Ever dreamed of tasting all the colors of the rainbow in a cookie? Yes, No, Maybe? Introducing delicious Skittles Cookies! Don’t knock em til you try em.

This post is all about how to make Skittles Cookies.

I decided to try the controversial Skittles Cookies recipe! I say controversial because some can’t imagine eating Skittles and cookies together as if it’s illegal. Initially, I cringed at the thought, but I’m also not a huge Skittles candy fan.

If you weren’t aware, Skittles has a brand of cookies that you can purchase at select stores. I have not tried them, but I did try this recipe, and while it’s very EASY and delicious, it’s also slightly high-maintenance.

For example, the candy must be FRESH. If you’re trying to get rid of old Halloween Skittles, this isn’t the recipe. Fresh Skittles have a thin shell exterior, but the insides are chewy. If you bake old Skittles in the oven, they’re almost impossible to chew.

Lastly, you DO NOT want to mix Skittles into the dough like chocolate chips. This candy is fruity and bursting with flavor, so follow the less is more strategy. Add three to four Skittles on top of the dough before baking. You want a cookie that’s sweet but doesn’t give you or your guests a stomach ache.

A buttery sugar cookie is used as the base for these treats, which balances the candy’s taste perfectly. Again, while this recipe is EASY, there are specific tips to follow to achieve a Skittles Cookie that’s moist and delicious with just the right amount of fruity flavor!

Easy Skittles Cookies

Do Skittles Cookies Taste Good?

Yes! BUT if you’re not a fan of Skittles candy or its fruity flavors, stop here and click here. Some people only want chocolate or peanut butter in their cookies, and I greatly respect people who know what they like.

As mentioned, this recipe is EASY. However, certain conditions must be met for them to taste successfully delicious. One, always, always use fresh Skittles. And how will you know they’re fresh? When you open the bag and taste one, it should be chewy (not hard) and SHOULD NOT stick to your teeth.

Ingredients You’ll Need For This Recipe:

No, we aren’t making the sugar cookie dough from scratch. This is the MAIN reason the word EASY was used in the title. The truth is, I was skeptical of baking cookies with Skittles, and I didn’t want to invest a lot of time into making the dough from scratch.

However, if you want to make the dough from scratch, you can. But be sure to follow the recipe instructions for adding the Skittles.

• 1 Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix, 17.5 ounces

• 1 Stick of Butter, aka 1/2 cup (I used salted butter.)

• 1 Large Egg

• 1/3 Cup of Skittles, approximately 4 Skittles per cookie. (Remember, the candy will only be added as a topping.)

Equipment Needed:

• Mixing Bowl

• Stand Mixer or Hand Mixer

• Baking Sheet

• Parchment Paper

• Cookie Scoop (optional but helpful)

• Oven

• Wire Cooling Rack

How Many Cookies Does This Skittles Recipe Make?

I recommend making 12 large cookies for this recipe. Because the Skittles are powerfully fruity, having a more extensive sugar cookie base will balance the taste. I used approximately 2.5 to 3 tablespoons of dough per cookie.

You can use a cookie scoop for accurate measuring if one’s available. I used a tablespoon measuring spoon and measured two heaping scoops for each cookie.

How To Make Skittles Cookies, Step-By-Step

Step 1: Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper, and set aside.

Step 2: Add the dry sugar cookie mix, butter, and egg to a mixing bowl. I purchased a bag of sugar cookie mix by Betty Crocker. If you bought something different, follow the ingredient and baking instructions on the back of the package, as it may be different.

Step 3: Mix the dough with a stand or hand mixer until the ingredients are incorporated.

Step 4: Grab the baking sheet lined with parchment paper, add balls of dough (2.5-3 tablespoons per cookie), and space them 2.5 inches apart.

Step 5: Using a spoon, slightly flatten each cookie and add four Skittles on top.

Step 6: Bake the cookies at 350 degrees F for 12-14 minutes. Watch them vigilantly. The cookies should look golden brown around the edges and soft in the middle.

Step 7: Once they’re finished baking, remove them from the sheet immediately and place them on a wire cooling rack.

Expert Tips For Baking With Skittles:

• These cookies taste best warm or at room temperature. DO NOT refrigerate them because the Skittles will become hard to chew.

• TASTE TEST the Skittles you buy to ensure they’re fresh and chewy. You’ll only need about 1/3 cup, so you don’t have to purchase a large bag.

• DO NOT add extra Skittles to this recipe, and DO NOT mix the skittles into the dough. Skittles have a robust fruity flavor, so less is more for delicious success.

• Be VIGILANT with the baking time. Overbaking these cookies will result in hard-tasting Skittles.

• Making large cookies is BEST, but if you want smaller cookies, only use 2 to 3 Skittles per cookie.

FAQs For This Dessert Skittles Cookie Recipe

What Are Skittles?

Skittles are fruity, multi-colored, and have a small button shape. They have a thin sugar shell imprinted with the letter “S.” The inside of the Skittles candies are chewy and bursting with fruit flavor.

Will Everyone Love This Skittles Dessert Recipe?

Unfortunately no. If they aren’t a fan of Skittles candy, they may not appreciate the flavor in a cookie. If so, you could easily swap out the Skittles for M&M’s.

What Year Did The Skittles Candy Come Out?

A British company introduced Skittles in 1974, and around 1979 they were introduced to the United States. An ad agency in New York advertised the candy using the slogan “taste the rainbow.”

Are Skittles Cookies Vegan?

Most varieties of Skittles do not contain any animal-derived ingredients. However, it’s important always to check the labels of special edition varieties that may be created.

Can You Really Put Skittles In The Oven?

Yes! However, watch the baking time closely for this cookie recipe because the Skittles will become too hard to chew if they’re overbaked.

Can I Add Skittles In The Batter?

I DO NOT recommend adding Skittles to the cookie batter because it will taste overly sweet and overly fruity.

Do Skittles Sugar Cookies Taste Extra Sweet?

Not as sweet as you might think! As long as you aren’t adding extra Skittles to the tops of the cookies or batter, you will get a perfectly balanced and tasty cookie.

Where Can I Buy Skittles Colorful Crunchy Cookies?

Skittles cookies are not available at every store, but Walmart sells them.

How Should I Store Skittles Cookies?

Store Skittles cookies at room temperature in an airtight container for up to three days. Avoid storing them in the refrigerator because the Skittles will become almost impossible to chew.

Can I Freeze Skittles Cookies?

Yes! If you have leftover cookies after three days, place them in an airtight container and store them in the freezer for up to three months.

Can You Make Them Ahead Of Time?

It’s best to enjoy these cookies right away. Over time the Skittles will harden, so it’s best to enjoy them fresh out of the oven or over three days at room temperature.

Final Thoughts On Skittles Cookies

I hope you find these cookies to be a delightful, sweet treat! Remember, to make successfully delicious Skittles Cookies, you MUST follow each step carefully. This is definitely an EASY Skittles recipe, but don’t veer off the recipe’s path!

Sharing is caring, so if you LOVE this cookie recipe, please share it with your friends and family on social media. You can follow career girl meets… on Pinterest, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for more home decor ideas, recipes, and gift guides.

Related Dessert Recipes:

M&M Rice Krispie Treats

Oreo Cookie Brownies

Creative Chocolate-Covered Oreos